Reports and Motions
2022 Policy Council Reports and Votes

Reports Submitted

Andersen, David   2022 Sep Report of SDS Community Service Awards Committee   (2022 Sep Report of SDS Community Service Awards Committee) Report

Eberlein, Bob   Proposed Modification of Bylaws   (In order to change the membership to be renewed on an anniversary of a member joining it is necessary to change the Bylaws. The proposed amendment to the Bylaws is attached as a report. The changes relative to the current Bylaws are marked. It is the recommendation Organization and Bylaws Committee that the amended bylaws be adopted by the Society membership following the process outlined in Bylaw XIII. The changes recommended are the minimal changes necessary to alter the term of membership. ) Report Supporting

Eberlein, Bob   Updated Policies Draft   (This is a draft of updated policies that conform to the new Bylaws and better match practice. It is being placed here for comment, and the attached Policies will be updated based on those comments so that the report will eventually reflect the policies adopted. The goal is to adopt them before Sept. 1, 2022 to facilitate the new rolling membership activation.) Report Supporting

Eberlein, Bob   System Dynamics Society Gift Acceptance Policies   (The Stewardship Committee has requested that the Society adopt and make available on the website a formal gift acceptance policy. The proposed policy is attached as a report. This has been reviewed by legal counsel. It is also partially dependent on the new Policies as they have been proposed separately. Formal adoption of these policies by a majority vote of the PC is requested for the August 31, 2022 meeting of the PC.) Report

Fisher, Diana   Report 2021-5/2022 SDS Precollege Education   (This report contains the activities of the SDS Precollege leadership team from 2021 through May 2022.) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council January 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council January 2022 Meeting Slides) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council February 2022 Meeting Slides    (Policy Council February 2022 Meeting Slides ) Report

Gary, Shayne   Replacement Policy Council member for partial term   (This message follows up on the February PC meeting where Scott Rockart was nominated to serve out the final year of general Policy Council member term that was vacated in 2021. The term expires at the end of the 2022 calendar year. We will vote on this partial term replacement in our upcoming PC meeting. Scott’s brief biography is below along with a link to his faculty profile at Duke University. Scott Rockart Brief Bio: Scott Rockart earned an MBA in 1996 from MIT and a PhD in 2001 from MIT in behavioral and policy sciences and management science. He spent two years as an assistant professor at London Business School (2000-2002) and then was an assistant professor at Fuqua from 2002-2010. He was also an assistant professor at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill from 2010 – 2016. Scott rejoined Fuqua in 2017 as an associate professor of the practice in the strategy area. Scott’s scholarly work is focused on policies for repeated decision making (e.g., decisions about pricing, investment, research, and product offerings). His research has appeared in Management Science, System Dynamics Review, and Strategic Management Journal. He currently serves on the editorial boards of the Strategic Management Journal and Organization Science. https://www.fuqua.duke.edu/faculty/scott-rockart)

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council March 2022 Meeting Slides    (Policy Council March 2022 Meeting Slides ) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council April 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council April 2022 Meeting Slides) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council May 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council May 2022 Meeting Slides ) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council June 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council June 2022 Meeting Slides ) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council July 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council July 2022 Meeting Slides ) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council August 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council August 2022 Meeting Slides) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council September 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council September 2022 Meeting Slides) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council October 2022 Meeting Slides   (Policy Council October 2022 Meeting Slides) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council October 2022 Meeting Slides    (Policy Council October 2022 Meeting Slides ) Report

Gary, Shayne   Policy Council December 2022 Meeting Slides    (Policy Council December 2022 Meeting Slides ) Report

Metcalf, Sara   Program Guidelines V0.07   (The Society Program Oversight Committee (SPOC) is posting the 2022 Program Guidelines in the Policy Council menu for reference. These guidelines will be discussed at a future Policy Council meeting. Comments and questions are welcome. These guidelines will be updated as needed by the SPOC Chair (Camilo Olaya) and ISDC2022 Program Chairs. The latest version may be accessed using the direct link.) Report  Link from authors

Metcalf, Sara   Supporting Material for Policy Council Response on Ukraine   (This report provides the full text of the materials and letters that are excerpted in the slides for our discussion at the March 30, 2022 Policy Council meeting. These supporting materials have been updated to include a letter from March 6 from a member offering help, and a project report referenced in the March 11 letter requesting to highlight Ukrainian SD work at ISDC2022. The updated materials are being filed for the continuation of the Policy Council discussion on April 6, 2022.) Report Supporting  Link from authors

Metcalf, Sara   Strengthening the Field Fund Guidelines   (The Strengthening the Field Committee has prepared revised guidelines to be voted upon at the July meeting. These revisions incorporate the more expansive vision discussed at our November 2021 meeting, in particular making sure the funds are open to the broader membership of the Society, not strictly those who represent Chapters or SIGs. The revised guidelines are posted as a report, and the current guidelines may be accessed at the link.) Report  Link from authors

Metcalf, Sara   Program Guidelines V0.08   (The SPOC is posting Version 8 of the Guidelines for the Programs of the System Dynamics Society for presentation to the Policy Council at our August 31 meeting. This document contains structural changes corresponding to the revised SDS Policies and will be subject to a vote of the Policy Council following approval of those Policies. The previous version is posted as document 1005 in the Policy Council Web Portal.) Report

Metcalf, Sara   Program Guidelines V0.09   (The Program Guidelines have been updated to describe Interactive Sessions as including Posters and Table Talks, which are a new format for IDSC 2023. Table Talks were proposed by ISDC 2023 Program Chairs and approved by the Society Programs Oversight Committee (SPOC) on October 26, 2022.) Report Supporting  Link from authors

Rich, Eliot   VP Finance Report for 2021   (Discussion of financial statements and historical trends. ) Report

Rich, Eliot   2023 Budget proposal for PC Review   (The Finance Committee report contains a proposed budget for 2023 and recommendations for reserve allocations. The PC needs to vote to accept both of these items. ) Report

Stave, Krys   Publications Options Analysis Report   (The report and slides attached provide a foundation for our discussion later today about what we want to achieve with the journal. Particular emphasis will be given in our meeting to the SDR Publication Options Analysis. Do we abandon SDR altogether and just publish a trade journal? Please review the slides and, if possible, think about the following questions: 1) What does the Society need to achieve with the journal? 2) What other information should the Publications Committee provide to inform the decision? If you have time and further curiosity, you can also get more information in the initial report attached. ) Report Supporting

Stave, Krys   SDS Publications Strategy (2022 Revision)   (This is an update to the 2015 report presented to the PC with a preface describing the way the Publications Committee intends to address some of the important issues highlighted in that report.) Report

Stave, Krys   Draft Potential New Submissions Categories for Discussion   (The Publication Strategy identifies three key areas for action that can reinforce one another and make the SDR a strong and vibrant journal going forward. To increase practitioner and educator relevance we are considering broadening the types of submissions, and the submissions review process, by adding two new submission categories as described below. These are in draft form, and a number of practical issues need to be worked out to bring them to fruition, but hopefully are helpful in articulating steps to be taken.) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council January 2022 Meeting Minutes   (Minutes of the January 2022 Policy Council meeting) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes February 2022   (Policy Council Minutes February 23, 2022 ) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes March Meeting minutes   (Policy Council Minutes March Meeting minutes) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes April 6 2022 extraordinary meeting   (Policy Council Minutes April 6 2022 extraordinary meeting) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Meeting Minutes 04.27.22   (Policy Council Meeting Minutes April 27,2022.) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 05.25 2022   (Policy Council Minutes for the May 25th. 2022 meeting) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 06.22.2022   (Policy Council Minutes 06.22.2022 submission ) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 07.18.2022   (Minutes for the policy council meeting held in Frankfurt before the ISDC.) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 08.31.2022   (This file contains the Minutes for the August virtual meeting of the Policy Council.) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 09.28.2022   (Minutes for the September Policy Council meeting held on Wednesday, September 28.) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 10.26.2022   (These are the minutes for the October meeting held via Zoom.) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 11.30.2022   (Minutes from the November Policy Council meeting.) Report

Stuntz, Lees   Policy Council Minutes 12.14.2022   (Minutes for the meeting held on Wednesday, December 14, 2022.) Report


Electronic and Recorded Motions Closed as of December 31, 2022

Source: Society Web Portal

Motion 1040: Subject: ISDC 2024 Program Chairs
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Bob Eberlein
Voting open date: 2022.01.10 Voting close date: 2022.01.20
Formal Motion: To approve Susan Howick, Mohammad Jalali, and Hazhir Rahmandad as Program Chairs for ISDC 2024, upon the recommendation of the Society Program Oversight Committee. All have agreed to serve.
Motion 1040 Passed (Y:17/N:0/A:0/NV:8)

Motion 1041: Subject: Proposed bylaw update
Proposed by: Bob Eberlein, Seconded by: Sara Metcalf
Voting open date: 2022.02.03 Voting close date: 2022.02.13
Formal Motion: That the amendments to the bylaws as detailed in report 1000 be put forward to the Society membership following the procedures of Bylaw XIII.
Notes on supporting material: Note - there will be discussion on this motion in Slack
Motion 1041 Passed (Y:19/N:0/A:0/NV:6)

Motion 1042(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the August - December 2021 PC minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: Sara Metcalf
Voting open date: 2022.01.26 Voting close date: 2022.01.26
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the August - December 2021 PC minutes
Motion 1042 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1043(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the January 2022 PC minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: William Glass-Husain
Voting open date: 2022.02.23 Voting close date: 2022.02.23
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the January 2022 PC minutes
Motion 1043 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1044(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the February 2022 PC minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: Jenson Goh
Voting open date: 2022.03.30 Voting close date: 2022.03.30
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the February 2022 PC minutes
Motion 1044 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1045(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to Approve Scott Rockart to partial PC member term
Proposed by: Bob Eberlein, Seconded by: Lees Stuntz
Voting open date: 2022.03.30 Voting close date: 2022.03.30
Formal Motion: Motion to Approve Scott Rockart to partial PC member term (expires at end of 2022)
Motion 1045 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1046(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the Housing SIG constitution
Proposed by: Stefano Armenia, Seconded by: Bob Eberlein
Voting open date: 2022.04.27 Voting close date: 2022.04.27
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the constitution of the Housing SIG of the System Dynamics Society.

Motion 1046 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1047(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the March and Extraordinary April 2022 PC mee
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: J. Bradley Morrison
Voting open date: 2022.04.27 Voting close date: 2022.04.27
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the March and Extraordinary April 2022 PC meeting minutes
Motion 1047 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1048(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the April 2022 PC minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: Jenson Goh
Voting open date: 2022.05.25 Voting close date: 2022.05.25
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the April 2022 PC minutes
Motion 1048 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1049(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the May 2022 PC minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: William Glass-Husain
Voting open date: 2022.06.22 Voting close date: 2022.06.22
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the May 2022 PC minutes
Motion 1049 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1050(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to Approve ISDC 2024 Organizing Chair
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Diana Fisher
Voting open date: 2022.06.22 Voting close date: 2022.06.22
Formal Motion: Motion to Approve Birgit Kopainsky as organizing chair for 2024 conference in Bergen, Norway
Motion 1050 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1051: Subject: ISDC 2025 Program Chairs
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Eliot Rich
Voting open date: 2022.07.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.10
Formal Motion: To approve Niyousha Hosseinichimeh, Rod MacDonald, and Karim Chichakly as Program Chairs for ISDC 2025, upon the recommendation of the Society Program Oversight Committee. All have agreed to serve.
Motion 1051 Passed (Y:18/N:0/A:0/NV:7)

Motion 1052(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the June 2022 PC minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: Jenson Goh
Voting open date: 2022.07.18 Voting close date: 2022.07.18
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the June 2022 PC minutes
Motion 1052 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1053(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve revised STFF guidelines as of June 24 version
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Paulo Goncalves
Voting open date: 2022.07.18 Voting close date: 2022.07.18
Formal Motion: Motion to approve revised STFF guidelines as of June 24 version
Motion 1053 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1054(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the July 2022 PC meeting minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: J. Bradley Morrison
Voting open date: 2022.08.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.31
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the July 2022 PC meeting minutes
Motion 1054 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1055(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: To approve the updated SDS Policies to align with Bylaws
Proposed by: Bob Eberlein, Seconded by: Sara Metcalf
Voting open date: 2022.08.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.31
Formal Motion: To approve the updated SDS Policies to align with Bylaws, including: change to a rolling 12-month membership, and phase-out of VP Electronic Presence.
Motion 1055 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1056(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to adopt System Dynamics Society Gift Acceptance policie
Proposed by: Bob Eberlein, Seconded by: Lees Stuntz
Voting open date: 2022.08.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.31
Formal Motion: Motion to adopt System Dynamics Society Gift Acceptance policies submitted on web portal August 19 (Report 1024)

Motion 1056 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1057(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve version 08 Program Guidelines
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Bob Eberlein
Voting open date: 2022.08.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.31
Formal Motion: Motion to approve version 08 Program Guidelines
Motion 1057 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1058(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to appoint Susan Howick and Hyunjung Kim as SPOC members
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Lees Stuntz
Voting open date: 2022.08.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.31
Formal Motion: Motion to appoint Susan Howick and Hyunjung Kim as SPOC members from 2023 to 2025
Motion 1058 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1059(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve to plan future hybrid ISDCs with an in-person
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Diana Fisher
Voting open date: 2022.08.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.31
Formal Motion: Motion to approve to plan future International System Dynamics Conferences using a Hybrid in-person/virtual model with an in-person capacity limit determined at the discretion of VP meetings with reduced-cost virtual attendance options
Motion 1059 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1060(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to appoint Bob Eberlein to the Publications Committee
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Raafat Zaini
Voting open date: 2022.08.31 Voting close date: 2022.08.31
Formal Motion: Motion to appoint Bob Eberlein to the Publications Committee (2022-2024)
Motion 1060 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1061(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the September 2022 PC meeting minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: J. Bradley Morrison
Voting open date: 2022.10.26 Voting close date: 2022.10.26
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the September 2022 PC meeting minutes
Motion 1061 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1062(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve Scott Rockart (2022-2024) as member of the St
Proposed by: Paulo Goncalves, Seconded by: Lees Stuntz
Voting open date: 2022.10.26 Voting close date: 2022.10.26
Formal Motion: Motion to approve Scott Rockart (2022-2024) as member of the Strategy Committee
Motion 1062 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1063(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the October 2022 PC meeting minutes
Proposed by: Bob Eberlein, Seconded by: J. Bradley Morrison
Voting open date: 2022.11.30 Voting close date: 2022.11.30
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the October 2022 PC meeting minutes
Motion 1063 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1064(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to appoint Ed Anderson to the Nominating Committee
Proposed by: Paulo Goncalves, Seconded by: William Glass-Husain
Voting open date: 2022.11.30 Voting close date: 2022.11.30
Formal Motion: Motion to appoint Ed Anderson to the Nominating Committee (8/2022-7/2025)
Motion 1064 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1065(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve holding the 2025 conference at Schaumburg
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: Bob Eberlein
Voting open date: 2022.11.30 Voting close date: 2022.11.30
Formal Motion: Motion to approve holding the 2025 conference at the Hyatt Regency Schaumburg on July 20-24, 2025
Motion 1065 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1066(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to appoint Oleg Pavlov as organizing chair of the 2025 c
Proposed by: Sara Metcalf, Seconded by: J. Bradley Morrison
Voting open date: 2022.11.30 Voting close date: 2022.11.30
Formal Motion: Motion to appoint Oleg Pavlov as organizing chair of the 2025 conference in Schaumburg
Motion 1066 Passed face-to-face vote

Motion 1067: Subject: Motion to approve the 2023 budget proposal
Proposed by: Eliot Rich, Seconded by: Bob Eberlein
Voting open date: 2022.12.07 Voting close date: 2022.12.17
Formal Motion: Motion to approve that the Policy Council adopts the budget proposed by the Finance Committee for 2023
Motion 1067 Passed (Y:17/N:0/A:0/NV:8)

Motion 1068: Subject: Motion to adopt FY 2023 designation of unrestricted funds
Proposed by: Eliot Rich, Seconded by: Bob Eberlein
Voting open date: 2022.12.07 Voting close date: 2022.12.17
Formal Motion: Motion to approve that the Policy Council designates the unrestricted assets of the Society for FY 2023 as proposed by the Finance Committee.
Motion 1068 Passed (Y:18/N:0/A:0/NV:7)

Motion 1069(Face-to-Face vote): Subject: Motion to approve the November 2022 PC meeting minutes
Proposed by: Lees Stuntz, Seconded by: Bob Eberlein
Voting open date: 2022.12.14 Voting close date: 2022.12.14
Formal Motion: Motion to approve the November 2022 PC meeting minutes
Motion 1069 Passed face-to-face vote


System Dynamics Society
Updated: December 31, 2022.