Abstract for: Peer Review Dialog Meeting

Since 2005, there has been an opportunity for joint reflection about the quality of the peer review process at each conference. In the subsequent conferences, discussin became more structured and this year, a substantial effort has been made. Still there remains work to be done in order to arrive at a policy that would achieve a satisfactory balance between paper and presentation quality on one side and other goals of the conference on the other. This year's meeting is the opportunity to discuss a set of indicators to express the presentation and paper quality perceived by attendees; also we can assess up to which point the new policies have yielded improvements. Reviewers, chairs and organizers are specially invited to give their input.